Sunday, April 2, 2017

High-Quality Standards for PBL @ASCD Empower 2017

High-Quality Standards for PBL

In discussing Problem Based Learning and inquiry-based pedagogy with teachers the conversation often leads to how to set expectations of quality work and assess student progress and understanding. The resolution almost always lands on using guidelines from the source I consider the richest and the original research-based organization on the matter, Buck Institute for Education.

In a packed session at this year’s annual ASCD conference I was fortunate to sit in a session, High-Quality PBL Guidelines for Practice. The session was lead by two Buck Institute for Education (BIE) authors, Rody Boonchouy and Brandon Wiley. Unlike most “sit and get” discussions at large conferences, Boonchouy and Wiley’s session reflected the values of BIE by engaging the audience to move around, reflect and discuss the pictured framework. From now until 2018 BIE is facilitating a process to create these guidelines for practice and is including the teaching community for reflection and input.

Towards the end of the discussion the authors asked the audience for one last cerebral dissection of the framework pictured. The question to the audience was how could they use this framework in their own work. The room sat quiet for a few seconds and hands started filling the air. One person commented the framework could be useful in reflecting in their own PBL practices and another commented that it could act as a starting point for PBL novices. Personally, I see this framework as a tool for students to reflect on their own experience with PBL in daily, weekly or in a final reflection of the process. For example, how or where could they apply each of the principles in the purpose, process and product of their experience. Their explicit examples included in their evaluation will give me a lens of reflection away from own bias and help to inform the process for the next group of students- as they and I author the next round.

Reflection is a vital, crucial and part of Problem Based Learning and any inquiry driven learning process whether it be given pedagogical context with “Maker”, “STEM” and so on. For some students the process of recall and reflection can be taxing. A framework such as this can provide students with a map to begin the process. Reflection is not a process to begin at the very end of the project, it should be a component of the ongoing project. Giving students this visual to check in with and journal about every day or every few days will help stitch together an overall reflection at the very end.

Thank you to those at BIE for all the research you do for inquiry teachers and our students. Thank you to the BIE ASCD Empower road team and to @bwileyone and @rodyboo for your memorable and engaging session.


Saturday, March 25, 2017

Connect.Empower. Advocate.Strengthen.



The president of ASCD, Ben Shuldiner, began this year’s annual conference with a strong message and one with a political undercurrent. He urged the audience of over 7,000 educators that this is a time to advocate for the profession in a time when, if we do not make decisions for ourselves, they could be made for us. This suggestion was obviously a nod towards what is happening in our current administration and messages from our current Secretary of Education, Betsy Devos. The easiest way to empower and advocate in education is for educators to organize, to become a network that fosters productive conversations, encourages progress and is supportive through laughter and feedback.

If there is one thing you can do to advocate for the teaching profession here at ASCD, or any conference, it is to turn to the person next to you in a session and introduce yourself. After that, start talking about who you are and what you’re about as a person and teacher. Then stay connected with that person by exchanging twitter handles or any way you can to keep the conversations going after the conference. (If you don't know how to use twitter, ask someone here!) Through the connection you’ve just made, connect to others in that person's twitter-verse. How can this one introduction to a stranger advocate for the teaching profession you may ask? When we create a strong network to share ideas, challenges and triumphs, the profession as a whole can only stand to become stronger and get through challenging tides whether they sourced in the White House or in the classroom.

You can connect to ASCD Empower 17 conference and the thousands of attendees here on twitter at @ascdempower17. You can connect to Ben Shuldiner at @bshuldiner and me at @D_L_Potts

Thursday, January 26, 2017

Beyond the What

This morning was a culmination of moments- a memory I will preserve in my mental jar of favorite teacher moments. After a lot of problem solving students finished their projects, their end goal had been reached. In watching them celebrate I let them know it was who they were during the process, rather than what they built that made me so proud.

Some background:
Every Tuesday and Thursday mornings I offer 40 minute sessions to students under different themes. Lately I have been offering "builder" sessions- students can build with Legos, Knex or Lego Robotics. The session is usually filled with third to fifth graders working on all types of projects and for some reason this chunk of 6 sessions only had three students. One student (3rd grade) started building with Legos the others (4th grade) jumped in with Lego We Do 2.0 kits. I noticed on the first day the robotics duo was quite comfortable so I raised the challenge of building some other projects during the proceeding sessions. When I presented the spirograph I did not realize there were no instructions out there in the forest of the internet and the best video is from a fantastic Russian girl who we came to be big fans of.

What unfolds:
The student building her Lego creation eventually let go of the side of the pool and decided to try out building with a We Do 2 Kit. We set her up with a kit and she built a rover by herself and figured out how to code it to go forward, backward and make sounds.When she asked me questions I would give her guiding questions sprinkled with reassuring comments in my confidence of her abilities. She built a stellar rover and programmed it to moved forward, backward and make sounds. I was proud because she went from what was safe to what was unknown. She trusted herself to take a chance and she went for it. Trusting the unknown is a big deal to some kids. Sometimes adults need to remember not all kids are risk-takers.

The two students (4th grade) building the spirograph mainly used this video from our Russian friend as their resource. Through pausing and playing the video they built, dismantled and analyzed their structure and personalized it with modifications. It took them 5 of the 40 minute sessions to complete the spirograph. We even called over the art teacher to give us some input on design during her morning set-up (thanks, Emily!).

In my memory jar:
What I am treasuring most is how each of these students started in their comfort zone and embraced a challenge. At any time they could have given up, walked away and they didn't. There was no grade or test involved to drive them. When it got hard, they voiced frustration and then figured it out. (I will admit there were times I wanted to offer a simpler project) It never became personal, they were supportive of each other and good spirited. What I am proud of most is who they were as people during the problem solving, moments of challenge and doubt not what they made that is most important.

Tuesday, September 6, 2016

Shaping the New Normal for Norms


I like to people watch. This summer I dedicateda good amount of time to observing how people of all ages use technology. I observed people on the subway, the street, in groups and alone. I observed people on their bikes, walking and pushing strollers.

My stretch of sleuthing came to a perfect point the other night. It was a gorgeous summer night and I was sitting outside enjoying the summer breeze while eating dinner at a restaurant. The twenty-something couple next to me had just been served their edible masterpieces and one of them proceeds to document the meal by taking pictures of her food (her world must know!). With the best of his manners, her friend sat there salivating at the smell of his food while waiting for her to finish this sharable moment. She responded to his hungry glare with "oh, I'm almost done with my hashtags". I wanted to turn to her and say "take pictures now and post later the man is hungRY!"

All of this intake has lead me to thoughts about how technology will continue to morph our social interactions in the short and long run if we do not have open discussions about our current actions. As I begin the school year I think about our students and the role technology plays in their everyday and what we, as a collective of adults, can do to be points of influence for this ever growing crop of new social norms.

As we begin the school year I urge you to think about how use technology in your classroom and how our practices as teachers are shaping the lives of our students with some questions:

How is the technology enhancing the lesson? I don't believe technology should be the only choice in a classroom. If a student wants to write an assignment by hand because that's their preference for processing information then it should be an option. In my opinion, technology should be used when it improves the workflow of the student's thinking and adds a unique element to a lesson.

If teachers are uncomfortable about what their students could be doing on a device then norms in the classroom need to be inclusive of technology. For example, at my current school we ask students to place their screen at a 45 degree angle when someone is speaking. If students continue to type, then their screen is placed all the way down.
Assignments, especially in the elementary grades, should reflect the personality of the student. If any tool makes an assignment look too perfect then think about ways the tool can be used to personalize the student's work. Making digital collages or printing out assignments and having students add illustrations is a way to personalize assignments.

How much screen time do your students have in a typical day? If students are working on their devices for more than twenty minutes they should be taking stretch breaks and looking away from their screens. (Let's table the discussion about the computer based testing for another time).
If students are working on screens in a group there should be an agreement for any person speaking to ask the group members to put their screens down and give eye contact. One person can record while the others talk. This isn't a matter of questioning one's ability to multi-task, it is about laying the expectations and practices for conversational manners. (It is important teachers model this too.)

What is your students' digital identity? How often do you talk with your students about their digital footprint? What is the path of posts they leave behind them? Many teachers have this discussion once during the year and feel it's said and done. Many middle and high schools have 1:1 programs with minimal discussions about digital citizenship or privacy agreements. Students can be engaged in these ideas by becoming activists in their school for responsible posting. Students should know who owns their digital information once it is posted and how fast it can spread. Students should also know their intentions with digital information, such as photos and videos, can be different than the impact on the people involved. This is not a discussion to have once a year as it intersects with the lives of students every day. In my opinion it is better to be on the side of proactive than reactive.


This year I am giving active effort to thinking about how I, as a teacher, model digital awareness. I am thinking about how often students see adults check phones for information that can wait until they are not in the room. I am thinking about how adults model clear and thorough communication expectations with Email, printed assignments and commenting. I wonder if we are empowering our students with teaching them how to ask someone to put away their phone, not to post pictures or know their rights when they select "accept" after signing up for a game site or app.

The task of building responsible citizens requires an understanding of the role technology plays in the definition. It's an uncomfortable place to take ownership of the actions we don't like seeing happening and admitting we do them too. The inclusion of proactive conversations on the influence technology is having on social norms is new territory for many learning environments. However you choose to define its purpose and role, I encourage you to begin the conversation with yourself, colleagues and students.



Monday, August 15, 2016

Good for You, You're Nuts: celebrating one year of #EdDlife


When I was seriously contemplating going to back to school for my EdD, I did what any reasonable person looking for life advice would do: I turned to Google for answers. After all, what the heck was I thinking entering into such a commitment? I would be handing over valued time and money to an uncertain path and outcome. I had just paid off my student loans for goodness sakes! Despairingly, the list of blogs churned up from my Google search were about as decisive as consulting a Magic 8 Ball.

Jump ahead and I am currently a year into my doctoral program. I felt I owed the kindred souls who might be consulting Google a piece of honest reflection and a little guidance. If anything, it will get me some karma points for a good parking spot. Warning: The list below should be read with a dash of humor.

Lesson One: Being Selfish
Over the past year I have had a lot of people look to me for convincing advise about earning their doctorate. First, I tell them they should not get their doctorate for the money or the fame or to be the smartest person in the room. The only reason anyone should go to school for their doctorate is this gnawing, unsettled Zelda-like calling that will not leave you alone until you finish this grand quest. My love for research and connecting the factual dots for others is a hobby and passion. I wanted to have conversations and surround myself with people who understand this part of my brain. I wanted to strengthen my research skills, knowledge of education issues and find mentors who would kick my arse a little. For me, this place was an EdD program.  

Lesson Two: Social Life
Some people are weary to go back to school because of the ramifications the workload will have on their family and social lives. I was worried about this too and it has been the source of much self debate this year. The first semester was the roughest to get through and I had to frequently revisit why I signed up in the first place. The members of my cohort and I are frequently reminded by our professors that the toughest aspect of our program is the perseverance. I quickly learned to balance time, how to function on slightly less sleep and politely turn down social invitations. Supportive friends are the ones who keep asking to hang out despite the fact that I disappear for long periods of time (especially at the end of the semester). Ironically being in school has taught me to savor moments away from books and be fully present in the moment. If you have children, the parental doctoral students I know have incredibly supportive partners, families and do much of their work after the children have gone to bed. I have learned there is a hidden doctoral class called "Balance 101". I should mention/give a shout out to my supportive administration who make it all possible too.

Lesson Three: Money, Money and Money
In my first semester I realized how much I had repressed any memory of the price of text books. Luckily, due to a decrease in my social life there is a little wiggle room in my budget! Textbooks are available for rent and with enough hunting, used books are fairly priced. If you're thinking of going back, the financial ugliness of loans should not deter your goals. There are ways to make it happen (insert Irene Cara song). I suggest the request for book retailer gift cards become a part of your holiday mantra for friends and family. For help with credits? I was lucky enough to find a program that has a generous scholarship for its students. Look into lists of scholarships, different types of loans and credit transfers (I transferred in credits from Masters Numero Dos and it has saved me a very large bundle). 

Lesson Four: Other Social Stuff
I have gotten used to this look people give me when I tell them I am a doctoral student. It's a
cross between "wow, good for you" and "you're nuts". When I first started I would respond with a list of reasons why I decided to go back to school. I stopped doing this when I became more comfortable in the second lesson, my program and my commitment. 

I have also learned there is a cut off line to others' interest level when I start talking
about my classes and research. I could talk about my research as if it was my party trick performing child or pet. I am still perfecting when the exact moment of T.M.I. begins on people's faces. Honestly, being a doctoral student can be a little bit lonely at times when you're outside of your cohort. The social stuff that surrounds being a doctoral student can be hard to navigate at times for me (insert Irene Cara song again).

This past year I have learned to ask better questions and have grown in ways I never could have predicted when I was consulted Google for life advice. Another year of classes is ahead of me and I am excited to dive head first into qualitative research. A year from today I will have completed my qualifying exam and writing my qualifying paper. I am depending on the guidance of my supportive professors much more than Google for direction when that rolls around.

A big, resounding amount of gratitude is sent to my family, colleagues and friends who listen to me struggle, rant and the occasional moments of clarity.

Friday, May 6, 2016

Fact Based Optimism


I have been meaning to introduce my other blog, Fact Based Optimism, which I started the December of 2015 after my first semester as a doctoral student. This blog is a place for me to share the connections I make in my research through the semesters. The goal in sharing this information with you is to generate a dialogue grounded in points of quantitative and/or qualitative data. I wanted a space to give people access to the connections I am making when I dive deep into all the information I have access to as a student.


The title of this blog space comes from the mind of Bruce Mau and is named with him in mind for two reasons. When I came across the simple, powerful phrase, "Begin with fact based optimism", I felt an immediate sense of connection because it neatly summarizes my current perspective of education as a doctoral student. After many discussions of what I "felt" was right for students, I realized the only way I can motivate institutional change is with facts. Finding the facts and data to transform practices in education is what drives my optimism during my doctoral studies. 

Secondly, Mau represents my curiosities of the creative minds outside the often impenetrable world of education. These minds includes the artists, problem solvers and innovators I look to for inspiration and a breath of cerebral fresh air. I find solace in their comfort to be amongst organized chaos and admire their ability to express their observations with evocative visuals.

I will continue to write here when I'm inspired to reflect about practice, observations and share what is happening in my teaching spaces. I look forward to us having a conversation in whichever space we meet.

Saturday, February 6, 2016

Some Recent Lessons with Elementary Maker Sessions



In my current role as an technology integrator I share the spaces I work in from day to day. This includes the space that hosts Tinker Lab, a before school session with a Maker theme. Each themed session is biweekly for two weeks. The space that I share is best described as "cozy" or "intimate" compared to other classrooms. The challenge for me was finding space and organization tools to store supplies and student projects.  I thought I'd share some of the tools, both in space and practice, that have been helpful.

Clear Drawers and a Label Maker  Masking or Painter's Tape and a Sharpie work just as well as a substitute for the latter. For some mysterious reason, if it's not labeled students don't look in it. I make it a habit to point students in the direction of the object they are looking for instead of the specific location. This communicates to students that guidance not answers are given, even when looking for supplies. I am also lucky to have a huge cabinet that I can store student projects in and empty shelves to put out supplies.

Self-Made Organizers I started my sewing and circuits session with students making their own supplies envelope out of paper, duct tape and markers. I did not give them clear, step by step instructions on how to make their envelope in hopes that this would set the tone for the next three classes. These envelopes were perfect for quick clean-up and I am going to use them again.
Key points in this was giving students a set amount of time for the building. Having students write their name on both sides helped with management of supplies and clean-up.

The Power of the Introduction At the start of Stop Motion Animation we talked about story structure, at the start of soft circuits we reviewed supplies and circuitry with a visual and at the start of game design students were given a handout to help guide their design and we talked about the important layers of games. As sessions went on we would stop and have a "check in" to discuss next steps and the direction of the session for the day. I found it powerful to show students that it's ok to stop and think in the design process. I make it a habit to respond to students with the question, "How might we...". It's a question that is a fitting response to many scenarios.

Paper is Design's Best Friend With soft circuits I had students draw out their design of what they wanted to make. This was incredibly handy when they went to the fabric because their paper design could be cut out and used as a pattern on the felt. Designing on paper was incredibly helpful with game design when students were thinking through the layout of their board game and other added features. It's been incredibly helpful to have scrap paper laying around or if preferred, a drawing App such as Explain Everything for students to record their thinking process.

Ratio With each session thus far, I have learned that a 10:1 ratio of third to fifth graders has been a lot to manage as it is quite a developmental range. With some of the sewing projects students needed help with more complex fine motor skills, such as curling LED legs and threading needles. I also found it helpful for students to draw the circuit on the fabric and then sew over it. During the Game Design session, I encouraged students to figure it out and look around the room for resource solutions. I've also learned to be vocal with students about the scale of their projects. Students come in to Tinker Lab with these amazing visions in their head of what they will be making. It's my job to guide that vision to a reality of what needs to be built in school and what can be finished at home. It's a conversation I have frequently in each session.

I have been amazed with our student projects! I just ordered shirt boxes to store the board games students made and I'm looking forward to our next session, Build Challenge. In this session students will build their prototype in 123Design and then build their prototype by hand using cardboard and whatever else we can find in the room. Wish us luck!

A HUGE thank you to my leadership who has been a huge support of Tinker Lab, helping me formulate my ideas to a realistic reality and give us the supplies we need to keep going.